Wednesday, April 13, 2005

Horizon milk not so great after all

Crap. A lot of folks, not just pregos like me and parents, have been trying to buy organic milk to avoid the scary scary hormones and cow torture and such. According to Salon, though, those cows aren't so perky. From this article, I quote: "Just now, though, at one of Horizon's dairy farms in central Idaho, the cows don't look too happy. Perched amid a stark landscape of sagebrush and expansive brown fields, long silver barns that hold 4,000 cows are linked like barracks in some covert operation. I drive down a narrow, cracked road toward the dairy's main office and pass open-air sheds about 20 feet away, where cows laze in crowded pens atop the brown hardpan of the Idaho desert. Just outside the milking barn, more cows are jammed into an outdoor corral. Amid clumps of dirt and snow, they are lined up, their bodies touching." Guess it's another brand for me (if I can find it, and afford it). There's got to be an economically feasible way of raising healthy animals for large-scale production. Or, with the way gas prices are rising and squashing our Walmart/mass-distributed econony, maybe it's time for the return of the local dairy farm, buying fresh eggs and milk from the dude down the road. Some friends raise chickens and I gotta tell you, a fresh egg is an awesome thing. I have no idea what real milk tastes like.

4 Comments:

At 9:58 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Rebuttal: No animal raised simply for provisions (eggs, milk - including for cream or cheese, flesh/meat) is going to be a "happy" cow. The Blue Bell ice cream ? Tasty, but I seriously doubt the cows really believe they are in heaven. It's not how its brain works.

That said - I want to state that I am NOT a vegetarian (I ate a cow I knew when I was 8 yrs old - there's really no turning back after that), but I understand the viewpoint. I personally believe there is a food chain, I'm at the top of it, and therefore I have the CHOICE to eat anything.

In order to *efficiently* obtain milk from cows (or goats or lambs), or eggs from fowl - it needs to be a streamlined process. I've gathered eggs from a henhouse - it takes a long while, esp. if you have to avoid a mad hen. I've milked a cow by hand - it's slippery and is a skill you have to learn.

Simply keeping the hens where they can't lay a hidden egg in a corner somewhere? That's caging and penning them. A cow has to give all its milk? That's going to entail hooking her up to machine that looks like those old perm machines.

Finding someone who *doesn't* do that? It's going to cost a pretty penny in labor expenses alone.

I think trying to find a creature that is "happy" to give up its offspring (eggs) or its offspring's sustenance is a fool's errand. Either we are harnassing the animal's talents and abilities or we are ministering to the animal. Either choice is up to you, but don't idealize either side.

Farmer's child, AEM

 
At 12:06 PM, Blogger bunny said...

Well!

I don't like Horizon b/c it always tastes like cow poop to me, but they also have the greatest market share, so that's the one you see @ SuperTarget. I'd rather be dairy free than buy that or rBGH tainted regular milk.

I prefer Organic Valley, or even that Christian one that's not totally organic but is rBGH free. You know, the one that comes in the glass jars? And for yogurt I do Stoneybrook Farms.

Oh - Organic Valley on pasturing!
http://www.organicvalley.com/utility/reading_room/pasturing.html

 
At 1:29 PM, Blogger marthachick said...

Cool thoughts, y'all. I don't have any illusions about happy cows, really. It's more about finding a compromise somewhere between efficient farming practices and healthy, not terribly mistreated or pumped-full-of-chemicals animals.

I stopped being a vegetarian, after all. But we do buy all-natural beef and chicken, on principle.

 
At 8:00 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Organic Rice Milk! You may find that this (or soy milk) is your only choice once the kiddo is born anyway (if you are breastfeeding). My wife had to give up cows milk because it upset the little one. And now I actually prefer a rice milk smoothie (w/ frozen banana, strawberry, vanilla) to milkshakes.

-Mike in South Austin

 

Post a Comment

<< Home